Skip to content
effecthub

AI Judge vs DoNotPay

Two fact sheets from our own research, side by side — pricing, platforms, API access and status re-checked by us rather than quoted from the vendors.

The short answer

Free plan
Only AI Judge (DoNotPay has paid plans only)
Higher Trust score
DoNotPay — 90 vs 69 for AI Judge
Best fit
AI Judge: Settling low-stakes personal or informal disputes · DoNotPay: Contesting a parking ticket, late fee or bank charge where the downside is small
Status
Both up at our last check (Oct 15, 2026)

From our own records as of each tool's last check. Anything we have not confirmed is left out rather than guessed. How we verify

AI JudgeFree web form that takes both sides of a dispute and returns a written mock verdict.DoNotPayGuided flows for consumer disputes, cancellations and paperwork

Side by side

FactAI JudgeDoNotPay
CategoryLegal & LegalTechLegal Research
Pricing modelFreePaid
Trust score69 / 10090 / 100
PlatformsWebWeb
Company—DoNotPay, Inc
Launched—2015
Last verifiedOct 15, 2026Oct 15, 2026

What our research says

AI Judge

A free curiosity: type both sides of an argument, pick a jurisdiction, get a written opinion. Useful for a second perspective on a roommate or freelance-invoice disagreement, and nothing more - there is no firm, no bar admission and no named operator behind it. The jurisdiction picker suggests more legal grounding than a language model can actually deliver.

Pros

  • Fully free with no account, card or sign-up wall
  • Supports multiple parties, not just two, with an add-contender control
  • Jurisdiction, dispute type, formality, length and mediation mode are all configurable
  • Mediation mode reframes the output toward reconciliation instead of a winner

Cons

  • No company, contact address or country disclosed anywhere on the site
  • Output has zero legal standing and no lawyer reviews it
  • Jurisdiction selection implies statute-level grounding that is not evidenced

DoNotPay

Useful as a cheap template-and-letter machine for low-stakes consumer annoyances, and nothing more — the FTC has formally ruled that presenting it as a lawyer substitute is deceptive. Treat any output as a starting draft you are responsible for.

Pros

  • Very wide catalogue of small consumer tasks in one subscription
  • Turns filings and letters into short questionnaires instead of blank pages
  • Cheap relative to any hourly legal help for trivial disputes

Cons

  • FTC order in Feb 2025 over 'AI lawyer' claims — quality was formally found not to match the marketing
  • No published pricing page, which makes the recurring charge hard to evaluate before signing up
  • Persistent user complaints about cancellation friction and surprise renewals
  • Homepage press section has not visibly refreshed since late 2024, so product momentum is unclear

Which one fits

Choose AI Judge if you need

  • Settling low-stakes personal or informal disputes
  • Getting a structured second read on an argument you are too close to
  • Seeing how a neutral summary of both positions might read

Choose DoNotPay if you need

  • Contesting a parking ticket, late fee or bank charge where the downside is small
  • Generating a first-draft demand or cancellation letter you will read before sending
  • People who would otherwise do nothing because the paperwork is annoying

AI Judge vs DoNotPay: the questions people ask

Does AI Judge or DoNotPay have a free tier?

AI Judge is free to use; DoNotPay has paid plans only.

More comparisons

All AI Judge alternatives →Browse all Legal & LegalTech →